// Copyright ©2015 The Gonum Authors. All rights reserved. // Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style // license that can be found in the LICENSE file. package community import ( "math" "reflect" "slices" "testing" "golang.org/x/exp/rand" "gonum.org/v1/gonum/floats/scalar" "gonum.org/v1/gonum/graph" "gonum.org/v1/gonum/graph/simple" "gonum.org/v1/gonum/internal/order" ) type communityDirectedQTest struct { name string g []intset structures []structure wantLevels []level } var communityDirectedQTests = []communityDirectedQTest{ { name: "simple_directed", g: simpleDirected, // community structure and modularity calculated by C++ implementation: louvain igraph. // Note that louvain igraph returns Q as an unscaled value. structures: []structure{ { resolution: 1, memberships: []intset{ 0: linksTo(0, 1), 1: linksTo(2, 3, 4), }, want: 0.5714285714285716 / 7, tol: 1e-10, }, }, wantLevels: []level{ { communities: [][]graph.Node{ {simple.Node(0), simple.Node(1)}, {simple.Node(2), simple.Node(3), simple.Node(4)}, }, q: 0.5714285714285716 / 7, }, { communities: [][]graph.Node{ {simple.Node(0)}, {simple.Node(1)}, {simple.Node(2)}, {simple.Node(3)}, {simple.Node(4)}, }, q: -1.2857142857142856 / 7, }, }, }, { name: "zachary", g: zachary, // community structure and modularity calculated by C++ implementation: louvain igraph. // Note that louvain igraph returns Q as an unscaled value. structures: []structure{ { resolution: 1, memberships: []intset{ 0: linksTo(0, 1, 2, 3, 7, 11, 12, 13, 17, 19, 21), 1: linksTo(4, 5, 6, 10, 16), 2: linksTo(8, 9, 14, 15, 18, 20, 22, 26, 29, 30, 32, 33), 3: linksTo(23, 24, 25, 27, 28, 31), }, want: 34.3417721519 / 79 /* 5->6 and 6->5 because of co-equal rank */, tol: 1e-4, }, }, wantLevels: []level{ { q: 0.43470597660631316, communities: [][]graph.Node{ {simple.Node(0), simple.Node(1), simple.Node(2), simple.Node(3), simple.Node(7), simple.Node(11), simple.Node(12), simple.Node(13), simple.Node(17), simple.Node(19), simple.Node(21)}, {simple.Node(4), simple.Node(5), simple.Node(6), simple.Node(10), simple.Node(16)}, {simple.Node(8), simple.Node(9), simple.Node(14), simple.Node(15), simple.Node(18), simple.Node(20), simple.Node(22), simple.Node(26), simple.Node(29), simple.Node(30), simple.Node(32), simple.Node(33)}, {simple.Node(23), simple.Node(24), simple.Node(25), simple.Node(27), simple.Node(28), simple.Node(31)}, }, }, { q: 0.3911232174331037, communities: [][]graph.Node{ {simple.Node(0), simple.Node(1), simple.Node(2), simple.Node(3), simple.Node(7), simple.Node(11), simple.Node(12), simple.Node(13), simple.Node(17), simple.Node(19), simple.Node(21)}, {simple.Node(4), simple.Node(10)}, {simple.Node(5), simple.Node(6), simple.Node(16)}, {simple.Node(8), simple.Node(30)}, {simple.Node(9), simple.Node(14), simple.Node(15), simple.Node(18), simple.Node(20), simple.Node(22), simple.Node(32), simple.Node(33)}, {simple.Node(23), simple.Node(24), simple.Node(25), simple.Node(27), simple.Node(28), simple.Node(31)}, {simple.Node(26), simple.Node(29)}, }, }, { q: -0.014580996635154624, communities: [][]graph.Node{ {simple.Node(0)}, {simple.Node(1)}, {simple.Node(2)}, {simple.Node(3)}, {simple.Node(4)}, {simple.Node(5)}, {simple.Node(6)}, {simple.Node(7)}, {simple.Node(8)}, {simple.Node(9)}, {simple.Node(10)}, {simple.Node(11)}, {simple.Node(12)}, {simple.Node(13)}, {simple.Node(14)}, {simple.Node(15)}, {simple.Node(16)}, {simple.Node(17)}, {simple.Node(18)}, {simple.Node(19)}, {simple.Node(20)}, {simple.Node(21)}, {simple.Node(22)}, {simple.Node(23)}, {simple.Node(24)}, {simple.Node(25)}, {simple.Node(26)}, {simple.Node(27)}, {simple.Node(28)}, {simple.Node(29)}, {simple.Node(30)}, {simple.Node(31)}, {simple.Node(32)}, {simple.Node(33)}, }, }, }, }, { name: "blondel", g: blondel, // community structure and modularity calculated by C++ implementation: louvain igraph. // Note that louvain igraph returns Q as an unscaled value. structures: []structure{ { resolution: 1, memberships: []intset{ 0: linksTo(0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7), 1: linksTo(8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15), }, want: 11.1428571429 / 28, tol: 1e-4, }, }, wantLevels: []level{ { q: 0.3979591836734694, communities: [][]graph.Node{ {simple.Node(0), simple.Node(1), simple.Node(2), simple.Node(3), simple.Node(4), simple.Node(5), simple.Node(6), simple.Node(7)}, {simple.Node(8), simple.Node(9), simple.Node(10), simple.Node(11), simple.Node(12), simple.Node(13), simple.Node(14), simple.Node(15)}, }, }, { q: 0.36862244897959184, communities: [][]graph.Node{ {simple.Node(0), simple.Node(1), simple.Node(2), simple.Node(4), simple.Node(5)}, {simple.Node(3), simple.Node(6), simple.Node(7)}, {simple.Node(8), simple.Node(9), simple.Node(10), simple.Node(11), simple.Node(12), simple.Node(13), simple.Node(14), simple.Node(15)}, }, }, { q: -0.022959183673469385, communities: [][]graph.Node{ {simple.Node(0)}, {simple.Node(1)}, {simple.Node(2)}, {simple.Node(3)}, {simple.Node(4)}, {simple.Node(5)}, {simple.Node(6)}, {simple.Node(7)}, {simple.Node(8)}, {simple.Node(9)}, {simple.Node(10)}, {simple.Node(11)}, {simple.Node(12)}, {simple.Node(13)}, {simple.Node(14)}, {simple.Node(15)}, }, }, }, }, } func TestCommunityQDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range communityDirectedQTests { g := simple.NewDirectedGraph() for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetEdge(simple.Edge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v)}) } } testCommunityQDirected(t, test, g) } } func TestCommunityQWeightedDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range communityDirectedQTests { g := simple.NewWeightedDirectedGraph(0, 0) for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetWeightedEdge(simple.WeightedEdge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v), W: 1}) } } testCommunityQDirected(t, test, g) } } func testCommunityQDirected(t *testing.T, test communityDirectedQTest, g graph.Directed) { for _, structure := range test.structures { communities := make([][]graph.Node, len(structure.memberships)) for i, c := range structure.memberships { for n := range c { communities[i] = append(communities[i], simple.Node(n)) } } got := Q(g, communities, structure.resolution) if !scalar.EqualWithinAbsOrRel(got, structure.want, structure.tol, structure.tol) && !math.IsNaN(structure.want) { for _, c := range communities { order.ByID(c) } t.Errorf("unexpected Q value for %q %v: got: %v want: %v", test.name, communities, got, structure.want) } } } func TestCommunityDeltaQDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range communityDirectedQTests { g := simple.NewDirectedGraph() for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetEdge(simple.Edge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v)}) } } testCommunityDeltaQDirected(t, test, g) } } func TestCommunityDeltaQWeightedDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range communityDirectedQTests { g := simple.NewWeightedDirectedGraph(0, 0) for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetWeightedEdge(simple.WeightedEdge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v), W: 1}) } } testCommunityDeltaQDirected(t, test, g) } } func testCommunityDeltaQDirected(t *testing.T, test communityDirectedQTest, g graph.Directed) { rnd := rand.New(rand.NewSource(1)).Intn for _, structure := range test.structures { communityOf := make(map[int64]int) communities := make([][]graph.Node, len(structure.memberships)) for i, c := range structure.memberships { for n := range c { n := int64(n) communityOf[n] = i communities[i] = append(communities[i], simple.Node(n)) } order.ByID(communities[i]) } before := Q(g, communities, structure.resolution) l := newDirectedLocalMover(reduceDirected(g, nil), communities, structure.resolution) if l == nil { if !math.IsNaN(before) { t.Errorf("unexpected nil localMover with non-NaN Q graph: Q=%.4v", before) } return } // This is done to avoid run-to-run // variation due to map iteration order. order.ByID(l.nodes) l.shuffle(rnd) for _, target := range l.nodes { got, gotDst, gotSrc := l.deltaQ(target) want, wantDst := math.Inf(-1), -1 migrated := make([][]graph.Node, len(structure.memberships)) for i, c := range structure.memberships { for n := range c { n := int64(n) if n == target.ID() { continue } migrated[i] = append(migrated[i], simple.Node(n)) } order.ByID(migrated[i]) } for i, c := range structure.memberships { if i == communityOf[target.ID()] { continue } connected := false for n := range c { if g.HasEdgeBetween(int64(n), target.ID()) { connected = true break } } if !connected { continue } migrated[i] = append(migrated[i], target) after := Q(g, migrated, structure.resolution) migrated[i] = migrated[i][:len(migrated[i])-1] if after-before > want { want = after - before wantDst = i } } if !scalar.EqualWithinAbsOrRel(got, want, structure.tol, structure.tol) || gotDst != wantDst { t.Errorf("unexpected result moving n=%d in c=%d of %s/%.4v: got: %.4v,%d want: %.4v,%d"+ "\n\t%v\n\t%v", target.ID(), communityOf[target.ID()], test.name, structure.resolution, got, gotDst, want, wantDst, communities, migrated) } if gotSrc.community != communityOf[target.ID()] { t.Errorf("unexpected source community index: got: %d want: %d", gotSrc, communityOf[target.ID()]) } else if communities[gotSrc.community][gotSrc.node].ID() != target.ID() { wantNodeIdx := -1 for i, n := range communities[gotSrc.community] { if n.ID() == target.ID() { wantNodeIdx = i break } } t.Errorf("unexpected source node index: got: %d want: %d", gotSrc.node, wantNodeIdx) } } } } func TestReduceQConsistencyDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range communityDirectedQTests { g := simple.NewDirectedGraph() for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetEdge(simple.Edge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v)}) } } testReduceQConsistencyDirected(t, test, g) } } func TestReduceQConsistencyWeightedDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range communityDirectedQTests { g := simple.NewWeightedDirectedGraph(0, 0) for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetWeightedEdge(simple.WeightedEdge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v), W: 1}) } } testReduceQConsistencyDirected(t, test, g) } } func testReduceQConsistencyDirected(t *testing.T, test communityDirectedQTest, g graph.Directed) { for _, structure := range test.structures { if math.IsNaN(structure.want) { return } communities := make([][]graph.Node, len(structure.memberships)) for i, c := range structure.memberships { for n := range c { communities[i] = append(communities[i], simple.Node(n)) } order.ByID(communities[i]) } gQ := Q(g, communities, structure.resolution) gQnull := Q(g, nil, 1) cg0 := reduceDirected(g, nil) cg0Qnull := Q(cg0, cg0.Structure(), 1) if !scalar.EqualWithinAbsOrRel(gQnull, cg0Qnull, structure.tol, structure.tol) { t.Errorf("disagreement between null Q from method: %v and function: %v", cg0Qnull, gQnull) } cg0Q := Q(cg0, communities, structure.resolution) if !scalar.EqualWithinAbsOrRel(gQ, cg0Q, structure.tol, structure.tol) { t.Errorf("unexpected Q result after initial reduction: got: %v want :%v", cg0Q, gQ) } cg1 := reduceDirected(cg0, communities) cg1Q := Q(cg1, cg1.Structure(), structure.resolution) if !scalar.EqualWithinAbsOrRel(gQ, cg1Q, structure.tol, structure.tol) { t.Errorf("unexpected Q result after second reduction: got: %v want :%v", cg1Q, gQ) } } } type localDirectedMoveTest struct { name string g []intset structures []moveStructures } var localDirectedMoveTests = []localDirectedMoveTest{ { name: "blondel", g: blondel, structures: []moveStructures{ { memberships: []intset{ 0: linksTo(0, 1, 2, 4, 5), 1: linksTo(3, 6, 7), 2: linksTo(8, 9, 10, 12, 14, 15), 3: linksTo(11, 13), }, targetNodes: []graph.Node{simple.Node(0)}, resolution: 1, tol: 1e-14, }, { memberships: []intset{ 0: linksTo(0, 1, 2, 4, 5), 1: linksTo(3, 6, 7), 2: linksTo(8, 9, 10, 12, 14, 15), 3: linksTo(11, 13), }, targetNodes: []graph.Node{simple.Node(3)}, resolution: 1, tol: 1e-14, }, { memberships: []intset{ 0: linksTo(0, 1, 2, 4, 5), 1: linksTo(3, 6, 7), 2: linksTo(8, 9, 10, 12, 14, 15), 3: linksTo(11, 13), }, // Case to demonstrate when A_aa != k_a^𝛼. targetNodes: []graph.Node{simple.Node(3), simple.Node(2)}, resolution: 1, tol: 1e-14, }, }, }, } func TestMoveLocalDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range localDirectedMoveTests { g := simple.NewDirectedGraph() for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetEdge(simple.Edge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v)}) } } testMoveLocalDirected(t, test, g) } } func TestMoveLocalWeightedDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range localDirectedMoveTests { g := simple.NewWeightedDirectedGraph(0, 0) for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetWeightedEdge(simple.WeightedEdge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v), W: 1}) } } testMoveLocalDirected(t, test, g) } } func testMoveLocalDirected(t *testing.T, test localDirectedMoveTest, g graph.Directed) { for _, structure := range test.structures { communities := make([][]graph.Node, len(structure.memberships)) for i, c := range structure.memberships { for n := range c { communities[i] = append(communities[i], simple.Node(n)) } order.ByID(communities[i]) } r := reduceDirected(reduceDirected(g, nil), communities) l := newDirectedLocalMover(r, r.communities, structure.resolution) for _, n := range structure.targetNodes { dQ, dst, src := l.deltaQ(n) if dQ > 0 { before := Q(r, l.communities, structure.resolution) l.move(dst, src) after := Q(r, l.communities, structure.resolution) want := after - before if !scalar.EqualWithinAbsOrRel(dQ, want, structure.tol, structure.tol) { t.Errorf("unexpected deltaQ for %q: got: %v want: %v", test.name, dQ, want) } } } } } func TestModularizeDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range communityDirectedQTests { g := simple.NewDirectedGraph() for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetEdge(simple.Edge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v)}) } } testModularizeDirected(t, test, g) } } func TestModularizeWeightedDirected(t *testing.T) { for _, test := range communityDirectedQTests { g := simple.NewWeightedDirectedGraph(0, 0) for u, e := range test.g { // Add nodes that are not defined by an edge. if g.Node(int64(u)) == nil { g.AddNode(simple.Node(u)) } for v := range e { g.SetWeightedEdge(simple.WeightedEdge{F: simple.Node(u), T: simple.Node(v), W: 1}) } } testModularizeDirected(t, test, g) } } func testModularizeDirected(t *testing.T, test communityDirectedQTest, g graph.Directed) { const louvainIterations = 20 if test.structures[0].resolution != 1 { panic("bad test: expect resolution=1") } want := make([][]graph.Node, len(test.structures[0].memberships)) for i, c := range test.structures[0].memberships { for n := range c { want[i] = append(want[i], simple.Node(n)) } order.ByID(want[i]) } order.BySliceIDs(want) var ( got *ReducedDirected bestQ = math.Inf(-1) ) // Modularize is randomised so we do this to // ensure the level tests are consistent. src := rand.New(rand.NewSource(1)) for i := 0; i < louvainIterations; i++ { r := Modularize(g, 1, src).(*ReducedDirected) if q := Q(r, nil, 1); q > bestQ || math.IsNaN(q) { bestQ = q got = r if math.IsNaN(q) { // Don't try again for non-connected case. break } } var qs []float64 for p := r; p != nil; p = p.Expanded().(*ReducedDirected) { qs = append(qs, Q(p, nil, 1)) } // Recovery of Q values is reversed. if slices.Reverse(qs); !slices.IsSorted(qs) { t.Errorf("Q values not monotonically increasing: %.5v", qs) } } gotCommunities := got.Communities() for _, c := range gotCommunities { order.ByID(c) } order.BySliceIDs(gotCommunities) if !reflect.DeepEqual(gotCommunities, want) { t.Errorf("unexpected community membership for %s Q=%.4v:\n\tgot: %v\n\twant:%v", test.name, bestQ, gotCommunities, want) return } var levels []level for p := got; p != nil; p = p.Expanded().(*ReducedDirected) { var communities [][]graph.Node if p.parent != nil { communities = p.parent.Communities() for _, c := range communities { order.ByID(c) } order.BySliceIDs(communities) } else { communities = reduceDirected(g, nil).Communities() } q := Q(p, nil, 1) if math.IsNaN(q) { // Use an equalable flag value in place of NaN. q = math.Inf(-1) } levels = append(levels, level{q: q, communities: communities}) } if !reflect.DeepEqual(levels, test.wantLevels) { t.Errorf("unexpected level structure:\n\tgot: %v\n\twant:%v", levels, test.wantLevels) } } func TestNonContiguousDirected(t *testing.T) { g := simple.NewDirectedGraph() for _, e := range []simple.Edge{ {F: simple.Node(0), T: simple.Node(1)}, {F: simple.Node(4), T: simple.Node(5)}, } { g.SetEdge(e) } func() { defer func() { r := recover() if r != nil { t.Error("unexpected panic with non-contiguous ID range") } }() Modularize(g, 1, nil) }() } func TestNonContiguousWeightedDirected(t *testing.T) { g := simple.NewWeightedDirectedGraph(0, 0) for _, e := range []simple.WeightedEdge{ {F: simple.Node(0), T: simple.Node(1), W: 1}, {F: simple.Node(4), T: simple.Node(5), W: 1}, } { g.SetWeightedEdge(e) } func() { defer func() { r := recover() if r != nil { t.Error("unexpected panic with non-contiguous ID range") } }() Modularize(g, 1, nil) }() } func BenchmarkLouvainDirected(b *testing.B) { src := rand.New(rand.NewSource(1)) for i := 0; i < b.N; i++ { Modularize(dupGraphDirected, 1, src) } }